Prove what your loyalty program is worth
Most programs can tell you what loyalty costs. Far fewer can tell you the value it creates.
Every month, accounting standards require your finance team to book what the loyalty program costs. No standard requires anyone to quantify what it creates. After enough months of a one-sided ledger, “cost center” stops being an opinion and becomes the default — and when the CFO asks what the program is worth, a weak answer costs you the budget.
The value a loyalty program creates is the amount it raises customer lifetime value — not what members are worth, but how much more they’re worth because the program exists. From there, you’ll learn the three mistakes that keep programs stuck in the cost-center spiral, and our recommendations for how best to reverse them.
You’ll hear:
- Why comparing members to non-members costs you credibility with finance — and what to use instead
- How to isolate what your program actually caused, separate from what would have happened anyway
- Where lifetime value jumps in the member journey, and which members and moments carry it
YOUR SPEAKER
Len Llaguno
Founder, KYROS
Measuring customer loyalty: common questions
How do you measure customer loyalty?
Most programs measure it with activity metrics — enrollments, engagement, repeat purchase rate. Those describe what members did, not what the program was worth. Measuring customer loyalty in financial terms means measuring customer lifetime value: the profit a member generates across the whole relationship, net of the cost of the points they will eventually redeem. That is the number finance can act on, and the one that connects loyalty to enterprise value.
How do you measure the value a loyalty program creates?
You measure the change in customer lifetime value that the program caused. CLV is the unit of value: lifetime revenue multiplied by lifetime margin, where margin is reduced by both cost of goods sold and the cost of the points members will eventually redeem. A program creates value when the revenue it drives outruns the margin it gives away. The hard part is isolating what the program caused from what would have happened anyway.
Why can’t we compare members to non-members?
Because of self-selection. Your more engaged, higher-value customers are the ones who join — they would have behaved that way regardless. Some program-caused behavior change is buried in that gap, but claiming the whole difference is a stretch, and anyone trained in finance will call it out. The cost is not just a wrong number; it is your credibility with the audience that matters most.
How should we estimate our ultimate redemption rate?
Ultimate redemption rate is meant to be forward-looking, and this is where most programs go wrong — they apply backward-looking assumptions to a forward-looking number. No program sits still; earn, burn, tiers and partners change constantly, so assuming the past repeats is the wrong assumption. That means running your single largest expense on assumptions you know are stale, until it catches up and forces a large true-up. The fix is predictive modelling of what is likely to happen, not a spreadsheet extrapolation of what already did.
What horizon should we use for customer lifetime value?
Long enough to capture compounding retention, but not infinite — no business plans that way. Most companies run 12, 24 or 36 months, sometimes five years, and a reasonable planning horizon is usually good enough. Three months will not do it. Two years is a conservative floor.
How long does it take to measure this properly?
Typically four to six months, layered onto existing data rather than replacing what you have. It starts with the vocabulary — getting loyalty and finance aligned on the same definitions — then the CLV models, then proving what the program caused, then studying where value concentrates across the customer journey.