Step-by-step ROI workflow for loyalty marketers

A Practical Framework for Estimating Loyalty ROI

This workflow is a pragmatic way to measure loyalty ROI with analytics and finance partners.

• It’s designed to help you answer: “What incremental value did loyalty create, and was it worth the cost?”

• It assumes you’ll use a mix of models (for long-horizon program effects) and experiments (where feasible, for short-term offers/campaigns).

• It’s not a guarantee of certainty—your output should be a credible estimate, with assumptions you can defend.

Step 1: Get rewards cost under control 

What you need

• Points issuance and redemption history, and the rules that translate points into real cost
• A forecasting approach that is responsive to customer mix and behavior change over time

What you do

• Build or validate a model that estimates breakage and expected redemption cost over long horizons
• Pressure-test whether your current assumptions are static spreadsheet averages or truly responsive to behavior change

What you get

• A forecast of the redemption cost for issued but not yet redeemed points
• A defensible set of cost assumptions for the ROI denominator

Step 2: Build a forward-looking customer value model 

What you need

• A clear profit basis (revenue vs gross profit vs contribution profit)
• Customer-level behavioral features (engagement, frequency, redemption behavior)
• Outputs from Step 1 so redemption cost is represented in value

What you do

• Build a forward-looking value model that predicts future profitability net of redemption costs, not just backward-looking spend
• Ensure the model can reflect how value changes when behavior changes

What you get

• Customer-level, forward-looking value estimates you can use to reason about incrementality

Step 3: Estimate baseline incrementality (the counterfactual problem)

What you need

• A definition of the baseline period and the world without loyalty
• The Step 2 model to interrogate and triangulate what the counterfactual might be

What you do

• Use your models to estimate what customer value would have been if the program did not exist
• Document the key assumptions and how sensitive results are to them

What you get

• An estimate of baseline incrementality and uncertainty bounds you can explain to finance

Step 4: Track year-over-year improvement with hard-number KPIs

What you need

• A short list of economic inflection points that correlate strongly with long-term value
• KPI definitions that are hard numbers, measurable and repeatable

What you do

• Select a small KPI set leadership can track, such as first redemption within X months or repeat purchase thresholds
• Quantify how changes in those KPIs map to changes in long-term value

What you get

• A year-over-year value story leaders can manage, such as when KPI X moves by Y, we generate incremental value of Z

Step 5: Attribute credibly (avoid self-selection and double counting)

What you need

• An understanding of what else is driving customer behavior, such as channels, promotions, and overlapping initiatives
• A plan for what can be tested versus what must be modeled

What you do

• Avoid member versus non-member comparisons as primary proof, as they usually reflect self-selection
• Use short-term tests where feasible, such as campaign-level points offers, to add statistical rigor and reduce double counting
• Treat attribution as an estimate and build a defensible narrative with multiple data points

What you get

• A credibility-safe narrative explaining what loyalty likely drove and why you believe it

Step 6: Build your ROI denominator and stage it if necessary

What you need

• Rewards and redemption costs, often the biggest and most material component
• Fixed costs where available, including platform, people, operations, and vendors

What you do

• Define a stable cost taxonomy for what is included and excluded and keep it consistent
• If you do not yet have a full program P&L, start with a practical first pass, often variable or rewards costs, and expand over time

What you get

• A denominator you can defend and an ROI that remains consistent as measurement matures

Sign up to receive our latest report "The Hidden Economics of Loyalty. Have the report delivered straight to your inbox when it’s released in March 2026: Sign up here!